This
Kenwood LS-P9000X "Digital" speaker is one of a
pair we recently reconditioned.
Although they were never what you'd call a landmark in Hi-Fi
speaker design, they look and sound big and impressive - a
real Japanese retro-classic.
Their owner had had them since they were new and kept them
in excellent condition.
Obviously, these babies had been part of the furniture for
so long that the lounge just wouldn't have looked the same
without them.
When they finally failed, the prospect of having to replace
them with someting new and different just had no appeal at
all for their owner, so he contacted us to see if they could
be fixed.
Many speakers of this vintage are discarded by people who
assume they can't be fixed - but very often they are repairable
and will continue to play for many more years after they've
been restored.
The
problem with these speakers was 'Rubber Rot' - a common issue
with speakers that have foam surrounds.
Rubber is an organic compound - and it does eventually decompose.
As the foam breaks down, holes will start to appear in the
suspension, as you can see in this shot of one bass driver.
The
rot in the other speaker was much more advanced and the foam
surround had completely gone. The surrounds are replaceable
so after the rest of the system was tested to make sure there
was nothing else wrong, the surrounds were expertly replaced
with new ones.
The Kenwoods went straight back to work and ultimate test:
the owner's kid's 21st. where they rocked the house!
How
much does it cost to repair speakers?
This
will depend on their type and condition. The example
above shows a common problem and a typical outcome. You
have to make the decision whether to repair or replace your
speakers. Sometimes, it's not just a matter of their
replacement value, but what they're worth to you. It'll
only cost you a phone-call to find out more... so give us
a call and we can advise you on the the best solution.
Back
Why
does my amp shut down when it gets hot?
Modern
consumer electronics is made more affordable by mass-production
techniques. Printed Circuit Boards (PCB) are no longer hand-soldered
(a very time-consuming process).
Hot solder is 'waved' onto the boards where it rapidly bonds
with exposed metal pads and leads.
If
you could slice through a PCB, the cross-sectional view of
a wave-soldered component lead would ideally look something
like this.
The secret of good soldering, is that all parts of the joint
must reach the same temperature and cool at the same rate
- otherwise, the solder becomes 'grainy' and the joint will
be weak.
Wave soldering however is a very fast process and often there
can be several joints that don't have time to reach the ideal
temperature where the solder forms the strongest bond.
Components heating up in use and cooling down when turned
off, result in expansion and contraction which can cause stress
fractures in weak joints.
Magnification
reveals an annular crack forming around this component lead.
This crack will ultimately cause the unit to fail. At this
scale, the crack is easy to see but in real life, they're
usually too fine to be seen with the naked eye.
These shots were taken from the amp board of an active speaker.
Active speakers (which includes subwoofers), generally have
poor ventilation and then of course, there's added vibration...
Another
pad from the same PCB clearly showing a gaping annular crack.
This one has really opened up! If only they were all as obvious
as this... usually, it takes some long, hard staring under
the magnifier to spot them.
This is the sort of thing that causes units to shut down when
warm - or to crackle and distort - or to need a 'technical
tap' (AKA a good thumping) to make them work.
In
this example,
from the unit's power supply stage, you can see small globs
of melted solder, burn marks from arcing and little 'blow-outs'
around the annular crack.
The resistance of the stress fracture, in conjunction with
the current flow has resulted in enough heat to re-liquefy
the solder. Electrical erosion, compounded by vibration from
the woofer did the rest.
It's a wonder the darn thing worked for long enough to get
into this state!
This
idealised drawing shows how a hand-soldered joint would look
in cross section.
The increased contact area and density along with proper molecular
bonding make this joint extremely strong, both physically
and electrically.
Conclusion:
There are many reasons an amp may shut down or go into
'Protection Mode' however one of the most common causes is
failure of wave-soldered PCB connections.
We often see integrated amps and A/V receivers, perhaps a
year or two out of warranty, that go into shut-down -- usually
after a spell of hot weather or a loud party (or both). Once
we have established that this is the cause, the faulty joints
can be re-soldered by hand.
Solder connections which are hand-made by an experienced technician
are rock-solid reliable -- and as a bonus, they usually sound
better too!
Back
Can
you convert foreign gear to 240 volts?
Since
the advent of e-bay, many Aussie audiophiles have taken advantage
of second-hand goodies from foreign vendors. As a result,
240 volt conversions have become a fairly hot item. Hardly
a week goes by that I don’t have at least one e-bay ‘bargain’
come into my workshop for conversion.
So, the answer to the question above is: “Yes, but with
qualifications”.
Generally speaking, products which are marketed internationally
will either be designed for multiple voltages – or at least,
be designed to be convertible.
This
beautiful classic Accuphase CD player is a prime candidate
for 240 Volt conversion.
The designers clearly intended this unit to last for many
years and they allowed for the possibility that it may change
continents in its lifetime.
Underneath
the chassis, Accuphase have provided easy access to the primary
circuit and a even small colour chart to facilitate re-wiring.
Thoughtful design, superbly executed.
It's easy to see why this is one of my favourite brands.
Products
targeted at a particular domestic market however, may not
be designed to be converted. This doesn’t necessarily mean
they can’t be... it just might be bit harder to do though.
At worst, these products can be operated on Aussie power
with an appropriate external transformer. If you’re
looking at a model that was never released on the Australian
market, it might very well fall into this category.
This
magnificent Marantz 2130 came via e-bay. It was made
for the U.S domestic market so there's no simple way to convert
it. Also, its 'collectable' status would be compromised
if its transformer was changed. In cases such as this,
we can supply an external transformer.
Can
everything be made to work on 240 volts?
Occasionally,
one comes across a product that is specifically designed
to make voltage conversion impossible. For some reason,
the manufacturer doesn’t want the product being sold outside
of their control, so they deliberately make it difficult
to convert.
This still doesn’t mean that it can’t be done, but it does
mean that the conversion will be unnecessarily expensive.
I have heard all sorts of opinions about this practice – most
of them negative – but I’m not about to use this article as
a forum to express my own.
How
much does 240 volt conversion cost?
Most
times, 240 volt conversion is a relatively straightforward
procedure. In these cases, a standard charge of $120
applys. Where a unit requires a special transformer,
or the manufacturer has deliberately chosen to make conversion
difficult, conversions must be quoted on a case-by-case basis.
So, if you have bought (or are thinking about buying) a foreign
'bargain' online, give us a call to discuss having it professionally
and safely converted for Aussie power.
Back
Why
is my system humming?
Because
it doesn't know the words, of course! (boom boom) But
seriously, several things can cause a system to hum, in this
article though, I shall address the eternal mystery of Ground-loops
(AKA Earth-Loops). These are the major cause of hum (and
other problems) in Hi-Fi systems, and probably the most common
and widely mis-understood of faults.
Many audiophiles have tried curing hum by adding extra earth
wires - sometimes tying them to the cold-water pipe - sometimes
even driving copper stakes into the dirt... but in reality
the cause is usually TOO MANY earth connections, not too few!
Usually, this comes from the fact that, in this country, the
regulation mains-plug has 3 pins, Active, Neutral and EARTH.
With respect to any single electrical appliance, this
is a good thing, because it adds an extra element of electrical
safety.
But when you connect several audio components together, they
form a SYSTEM and it is important for this system to have
a logical SYSTEM GROUND -- otherwise, it will just have a
mish-mosh of un-planned earth connections, depending on your
particular mix of components and their respective power cables.
Once the simple "Ground Rules" are understood, you
will be able to banish ground-loops and their nasty effects
from your system forever! Once again, let's go back
to the basics.
Audio
Signal Basics
We
like to think it's music going through our wires, but it's
actually just an electric current flowing in a circuit between
say, your CD player and your amp. It's called a circuit
because electric currents always follow a circular path (logically,
not physically). The electric current in this circuit
is the 'analogue' of the music signal it represents.
The
standard for unbalanced connections in Hi-Fi is the RCA plug.
With the exception of a small handful of European brands,
just about everything connects with these. The centre
pin carrys the music signal which travels down the centre
of the cable. The outer ring completes the circuit by
providing the return path, via the 'shield' which usually
takes the form of a wire braid wrapped around the signal wire.
In unbalanced circuits, the return path is always the unit's
'Ground' - which means that the outer ring is ultimately connected
to the metal chassis.
As
mentioned above, the connection between your CD player and
your amp is a circuit because electric currents always follow
a circular path.
This electric current (the analogue of your music signal)
travels down the centre of the cable and returns via the outer
shield... or does it?
Electricity ALWAYS follows the line of least resistance --
and we know that the shield which is supposed
to be the return-path for the signal is also connected to
the chassis and the chassis is connected to the Earth pin
of the mains plug.
So...
what happens if the mains cable has less resistance than the
shield of your RCA cable? Well, it becomes part of the
signal path - that's what!
The
signal current returns, not via the shield, as it should -
but via the mains cables which are connected together by your
power-board - and in the process, it picks up interference
from the mains, resulting in the noise that we know as HUM.
But hum is not the only potential problem here... remember,
the Earth pin of the power plug, is also connected by the
house-wiring to your TV, the fridge, the microwave, the computer,
the power pole in the street, the house next door, the butcher,
the baker... you get the drift. In theory, in "a
perfect world", the Ground is meant to be SILENT... but
guess what?... it ain't a perfect world!
A ground-loop can cause your system to pick up all manner
of electrical garbage - and in extreme cases, it can even
result in instability and catastrophic failure.
So...
What's the solution?
Consider the diagram on the right, and notice how it resembles
a tree with a root, a trunk and some branches. If your
system ground is structured in this way, ground-loops
are eliminated. All units are grounded to the pre-amp
via their interconnects, and ONLY the pre-amp connects to
mains Earth, preferrably via the best power cable you have
on hand.
Alternatively,
this arrangement will work if you have a power amp with heavy
mains cable -- you can use it as the 'trunk' of the tree.
Remember, this is a map of our system ground only,
not the power connections or the signal path.
The general tree-shaped map still applys, regardless of your
particular setup.
Removing
any additional ground wires forces the signal currents to
do what they should
i.e. to return via the correct path, the interconnect shields...
BUT
Before you take a hacksaw to the Earth pins on your mains
cables... make sure you know what you're doing
How
to Fix it
First,
be aware that ground-loops are only responsible for hum about
95% if the time. If the hum you are hearing is coming
from inside a faulty component, no amount of mucking about
with cables is going to cure it. Hum can also mean you
have a faulty cable somewhere. So you should first try
a couple of tests.
"The Hard Way" (recommended
if all else fails)
To test where the hum is coming from, you can try disconnecting
EVERYTHING except the power amp and speakers, and then switch
on the amp and listen closely to the speakers. If it
has NOTHING ELSE connected to it, the amp should not hum...
if it does, then the amp is faulty, pure and simple (so call
me, I'll fix it, OK?).
If there's no hum, switch off, connect the pre-amp ONLY to
the power amp and once again, switch on and listen to the
speakers. Keep repeating the above procedure, each time
adding another component until you find the one that makes
the system hum.
"The Easy Way" (try this
first!)
You will need a very sophisticated piece of equipment - and
you have to make it yourself!
"The
Floater"
Grab
a common old double adapter (the pyramid-shaped ones work
best) and a screwdriver. Undo the screw that holds it
together and pull the entire earth-pin assembly out and then
put it back together.
Throw the earth thingy into the drawer of bits you're keeping
in case they come in handy some day.
Using a CD marker (or similar), write "FLOATER"
(or any scary message that'll stop your spouse using it on
the kettle and the toaster) on the side.
Keep away from children.
Armed
with your Floater and your new 'system ground tree',
seek and destroy all ground-loops. Start by isolating
the source components first.
Don't forget that your RCA cables must now earth the floated
components, so make sure they make good contact.
If
your interconnects aren't up to the job, then you'll either
need to upgrade your cables... OR
If just the RCAs are no good, talk to me about having your
cables refurbished with some high quality plugs, like these
gorgeous WBT Toplines (my personal favorite).
That annoying hum will soon be just a bad memory and you won't
believe how good the music sounds against a black background
of silence!
Back
Balanced
vs. Unbalanced
What's
the real story on balanced lines? Are they really so
much better than 'normal' unbalanced ones? Balanced
lines were originally only seen in professional audio systems
such as used in recording studios. They were hardly
ever seen in Hi-Fi systems except for a few high-end units
which were built to professional standards.
Over the last decade or so, balanced lines have become more
common in domestic Hi-Fi with many components now offering
balanced input/output options.
To properly appreciate the advantages of balanced lines, it
is helpful to understand a little about how they work.
Audio
Signal Basics
We
like to think it's music going through the wires, but it's
actually just an electric current flowing in a circuit between
say, your CD player and your amp. It's called a circuit
because electric currents always follow a circular path (logically,
not physically). The electric current in this circuit
is the 'analogue' of the music signal it represents.
The
standard for unbalanced connections in Hi-Fi is the RCA plug.
With the exception of a small handful of European brands,
just about everything connects with these. The centre
pin carrys the music signal which travels down the centre
of the cable. The outer ring completes the circuit by
providing the return path, via the 'shield' which usually
takes the form of a wire braid wrapped around the signal wire.
In unbalanced circuits, the return path is always the unit's
'Ground' - which means that the outer ring is always connected
to the metal chassis.
This
is called "Unbalanced" because there is only one
signal line which is referred to the Ground which (in a perfect
world) represents 'zero volts' or silence. The significance
of this will become much clearer when you compare it with
the Balanced circuit (below).
The
signal can be represented graphically like this...
The line through the middle represents zero volts, which is
the same potential as the RCA plug's outer ring and the Ground
(or chassis) of the equipment. The wave shape represents
a sound-wave as positive and negative motion of electrical
current.
The
same signal in a balanced circuit looks like this...
The signal is not referred to the chassis, instead, it is
referred to its own mirror-image. The music signal is
carried by the difference between the two identical,
but opposite electric currents... as opposed to the difference
between one current and the unit's chassis.
Obviously,
this 'balancing act' will require an extra signal line &
therefore a different plug.
The
standard connector for balanced lines is the XLR (sometimes
called a "Canon plug") which has two signal pins
plus a shield pin.
Unfortunately, XLRs are quite a bit bigger than RCAs but they're
rugged, reliable and relatively inexpensive.
Pros
and Cons
So,
why does this extra line make such a difference? Well,
there are several reasons...
For one, the signal does not 'sit' on the Ground as it does
in an unbalanced circuit -- remember, the Ground is also connected
to the unit's chassis, which is also connected to the Earth
pin of the power plug, so it's also connected by the house-wiring
to your TV, the fridge, the microwave, the computer, the house
next door etc. etc.
As mentioned above, "in a perfect world", the Ground
is meant to represent SILENCE... but the problem is... it
ain't a perfect world!
But the really BIG bonus is a thing called "Common
Mode Rejection" - do read on!
Common
Mode Rejection is all about how the circuit behaves in the
presence of unwanted signals. Unwanted signals? Consider
this: Every wire is also an antenna for interference and no
shield is ever 100% effective.
Remember, The music signal is carried by the difference
between the two identical, but opposite lines... which implys
that: if there is no difference, there is no signal.
Now, if one line sees some interference, the other one will
too... The graphic on the left shows what happens when
a balanced circuit picks up a 'spike' of interference. As
there is no difference in the spikes, they have virtually
no effect on the signal.
Another
huge bonus that comes from the balanced connection is the
abscence of ground-loops. These are the major cause
of hum in Hi-Fi systems, and probably the most widely mis-understood
and common of problems.
Ground-Loops
in Unbalanced Systems
As
mentioned above, the connection between say, your CD player
and your amp is a circuit because electric currents always
follow a circular path.
The music signal which travels down the centre of the cable
and the outer shield completes the circuit by providing the
return path... or does it?
Electricity ALWAYS follows the line of least resistance --
and we know that the shield that is supposed
to be the return-path for the signal is also connected to
the chassis and the chassis is connected to the Earth pin
of the mains plug.
So...
what happens if the mains cable has less resistance than the
shield of your RCA cable? Well, it becomes part of the
signal path - that's what!
The
signal current returns, not via the shield, as it should -
but via the mains cables which are connected together by your
power-board - and in the process, it picks up interference
from the mains, resulting in the noise that we know as HUM.
Because the balanced connection does not rely on the shield
to return the signal current, ground-loops are not a problem.
Back
Why
should I get my unit modified?
If
you're reading this, the chances are, you're already thinking
about how you could make your system sound better than it
does. The options available to you are as follows:-
Buy better equipment...
No explanation necessary here. Visa or MasterCard?
Improve the environment...
Acoustic treatments for your listening room, proper location
of your system components, power conditioners etc.
Use better connections...
Better speaker wire, higher quality cables, gold-plated connectors.
(You're not still using the wires that came in the
box are you? Uh-Oh!)
Modifications...
OK, you're using the good wire, you've tweaked the lounge
as much as the spouse can take, you don't want to buy a load
of new stuff - but ehhhh... the thrill has gone? This is the
time to talk about modifications.
But...
isn't it already pretty good?
When
you bought this unit, you read the owner's manual and it said:
"Congratulations, you just bought the finest audio component
in the world." (they all say that).
Now, do you think that was written by the designer, who's
under the hammer from the board of directors to cut costs?
Or was it written by some marketing doofus* who's under the
hammer from the board of directors to make it look like they're
not cutting costs?
Even if the above does not apply, there have probably been
several improvements in component technology since the unit
was first conceived.
Also, is the wiring inside the box of the same quality as
your good cables outside the box? Or has the 'jewel in the
crown' become the weakest link?
* (my apologies if you are a marketing doofus!)
Can
mods damage the unit?
That's
like asking: "Will cosmetic surgery make me ugly?"
Only if carried out by someone who doesn't know what they're
doing.
Same answer.
Can
mods be reversed?
Usually,
they can - depending on the exact nature (and extent) of the
mod. I normally try to make mods reversible but again, it
depends on how far you want to take it.
Wiring and component upgrades are generally reversible
anything which involves drilling holes generally isn't.
What
can mods do for me?
This
depends on what you've got - and of course, what you'd like
to get from it. So, just as a guideline, here are some typical
results from expert modifications.
Improved
low-level performance Improved
clarity at higher volumes Tighter,
more controlled bass Sweeter,
clearer highs Better
resolution of inner detail Faster,
cleaner transients Improved
stereo imaging and depth Lower
noise, hum and distortion Increased
efficiency and power
Where
do I start?
Call
me! Call me now! But seriously, let's
talk about what sort of mods will work for your setup. Occasionally,
I'll get a punter who'll send me a unit with a note saying
something like: "See what you can do with this"
but I prefer not to work like that.
In order to suggest a sensible direction for your system,
I need to know:
What
is the weakest link (the obvious place to start)
Where
you feel it needs improvement
The
sort of result you'd like to achieve
This
much will only cost you a phone call (See? Talk is
cheap!)
From here, I will assess the unit - a MOST important step!
I have occasionally seen cases where some 'expert' has attempted
to modify a unit in an attempt to remedy a sonic deficiency
that was actually due to a minor electronic fault in the unit!
Sometimes, a simple repair is all that's needed to restore
the proper level of performance to a unit that still works
- but just sounds a bit 'ordinary'.
Next, I will prepare a quotation for you with a few options.
What
might be involved?
Again,
depending on the unit and your expectations, a modification
could include any (or all) of the following:-
Design
review and treatment of inherent structural deficiencies Substitution
of standard parts with superior audio-grade components Replacement
of internal wiring with improved cables Replacement
of original valves (if applicable) with better types Bypassing
unused features which impact the signal path Augmentation
of components to alter their sonic attributes Additional
components to improve noise immunity and stability Removal
and replacement of worn or oxidized connections Re-orientation
of internal cabling to prevent unwanted interactions Acoustic
treatment and/or reinforcement of cabinet/chassis
"Are
we going for the 'Extreme Make-over' or shall we just do the
Botox today?"
Back
Class-A,
Class-B... What's it all about?
I’m
often asked about amplifier ‘class’. If you hang around audio
long enough, you’ll hear and read about; Class-A, Class-B,
Class-D, Class-G and Class-H which are really just categories
of amplifier design used in audio.
I have never seen a good, non-technical explanation of amplifier
class (sort of like… if you can understand a paper on amplifier
class, then you don’t have to?) so it occurred to me that
only non-technical people ever ask what amp class means.
So, if you’re looking at an amp that says “Class-D” (or whatever)
on it and you’re thinking: “What the heck does that mean?”
then this article is for you!“
Although Class-A is theoretically simpler than Class-B, I
think it’s actually easier to explain Class-B first.
Class-B
"The Working Class"
Class-B
amplifiers are the most common type on Earth, mostly because
they’re traditionally the cheapest to make. You have already
heard several Class-B amps today, even though you didn’t know
it – they’re in your clock radio, your TV, your car stereo,
your computer, the P.A. at school or at work, the elevator,
the shopping mall – to name a few.
Consider the simple wave shown below.
The
line through the middle is just for reference.
Imagine that the curves above this line represent the speaker
cone moving forward and those below represent the cone moving
backward.
Class-B
amps always have at least two output devices (per channel),
one which is positive and one which is negative.
The
positive device switches on to drive the speaker forward –
its contribution to the output is shown here.
And
the negative device does the same job below the line. This
arrangement is often referred to as “Push-Pull”.
When
there is a silence, the wave ‘flat-lines’ - the speaker is
at rest and both of the Class-B amp’s output devices are switched
off which saves both power and cost.
Now,
for the bad news… The positive and negative devices are almost
never exact ‘bookends’ so they don’t always jive together.
The result is “Crossover Distortion” – as shown in this (highly
exaggerated) graphic.
The
level of Crossover Distortion is constant, regardless of volume
which means that when the volume is high, it only accounts
for a small percentage of the signal. When the volume is
low however, Crossover Distortion begins to dominate.
Class-A
"The Upper Class?"
Class-A”
seems to have a mystique about it – probably because people
associate “A” with the ‘perfect score’ and ‘the top of the
class’ and maybe even ‘First Class’ but it ain’t necessarily
so.
In a Class-A amp, the output devices never actually switch
off which completely eliminates Crossover Distortion. The
downside of this is that the amp is constantly running flat
out, sucking power and getting HOT – even during periods of
silence! Class-A amps may also be “Push-Pull” meaning that
they have both Positive and Negative output devices (like
the Class-B amp does) or they can be “Single-Ended”.
In
a Single-Ended amp, only one output device does all the work
– it only pushes ‘up’ and relies on the ‘weight’ of the load
to bring it back down. This is a very simple setup and produces
no crossover distortion at all.
The
downside, once again, is that the device works all the time,
even during silence. Imagine the guy with the barbell holding
it dead still, exactly half-way up and you’ll have a pretty
good idea of what this amp has to do. These amps are working
hard all the time and as a result they get very hot, consume
huge amounts of power and generally need some sort of elaborate
cooling system.
Single-Ended amps can only produce comparatively small amounts
of usable output power because they are so inefficient and
it’s therefore too expensive to manufacture S.E. amps that
can produce more than a few Watts.
Having said that though, Single-Ended amplifiers continue
to enjoy cult-like support from a hard-core of devotees.
How do they sound? Well, just about every mantle or console
valve radio made up until about the late 1950s had a single-ended
output stage and most folks thought they didn’t sound too
bad at all!
Quick
Summary, A vs. B
Class-B
is highly efficient, produces lots of Watts,
runs cool and is cheap to make but has its own special
type of distortion.
Class-A is highly inefficient, expensive to make, eats electricity,
runs hot and produces lower Wattage but has extremely
low distortion.
Class-B is ALWAYS Push-Pull.
Class-A may be Push-Pull OR Single-Ended.
Single-Ended is ALWAYS Class-A*
*(except in non-audio applications)
So, does this mean that Class-A is reserved for the rich and
famous and the rest of humanity must live with Class-B? Not
completely – read on!
Class-AB
– "The Spirit of Compromise"
This
‘half-breed’ is the workhorse of ‘middle-shelf' Hi-Fi. Not
too expensive, not too cheap, not too hot, not too cold –
you get the idea. Simply put, Class-AB is a variation of
Class-B with greatly reduced Crossover Distortion. It works
by having each of the devices in the Push-Pull output ‘just
a little bit’ turned on.
Visualise if you will, the runners in a relay race. The second
guy that’s waiting for the baton doesn’t just stand there…
he starts running just before the first guy stops, matching
his speed, so the baton never actually slows down.
Now consider the following wave drawing. The shaded band
through the middle represents a small region in which the
Positive and Negative output devices are both turned on.
At
low volumes, the signal stays within the shaded region so
the amp behaves like Push-Pull, Class-A. When the volume increases
past the top of this region, the bottom (negative) device
switches off and allows just the top device to complete the
rest of the positive excursion as per Class-B.
The
amp then drops back through the Class-A region until the top
device switches off and allows the bottom device to complete
the negative part of the wave. The end result is that you
get a little bit of Class-A purity at low volumes and power
like a Class-B at high volumes.
Added to the fact that it won’t scorch the carpet and you
won’t need a second mortgage to own one, this has got to be
a winner!
I’m skipping directly to Class-G now, just because it follows
on nicely from the above discussion.
Class-G
"The best of both worlds?"
An
amplifier which combines the desirable attributes of Class-A
and Class-B (but does not suffer any of the disadvantages
of either) is the ‘Holy Grail’ of amp design. As seen above,
Class-AB is a pretty good compromise but a compromise nonetheless.
So what’s the next logical step? Roughly, the line of thought
goes like this: “It’s not economical to make a really big
Class-A amp… but what if we could make a tiny little Class-A
amp that gets bigger when you turn it up?” Sounds
like a wacky idea at first but it can actually work.
So, we have a little Class-A amp that stays in control of
the speaker at all times and it’s small enough that it’s not
too inefficient or uneconomical to make -- but what happens
when it runs out of power? The Class-G circuit ‘turns up
the gas’ and supplies the extra power to the little amp as
and when required and then ‘throttles back’ again when not
needed.
There have been many variations on this basic idea and it’s
been called “Rail Commutation”, “Current Dumping” and goodness
knows what else but it was Hitachi
who called it Class-G (don’t ask why) when they released some
fairly impressive hardware based on this idea back in the
late 1970s.
Now, some hard-nosed engineers will tell you that there is
no such thing as Class-G (it is sort-of an ‘unofficial’ class
as it was named by a famous company as opposed to a bunch
of faceless academics) but the term has become legitimate
enough through common usage.
And before some bloody genius e-mails to tell me that rail-switching
amplifiers can actually be Class-A, Class-B or Class-AB (or
that Single-Ended amplifiers can also be Class-C or Class-D),
I would just like to add:-
1. I’m trying to keep this simple, remember?
2. If you’re so smart, how come you’re
reading this?
Class-H
"Friend or Foe?"
Class-H
is really very similar to Class G. The major difference is
that where Class-G sort of ‘shifts gears’ only when the amp
needs more power, Class-H’s power is continuously modulated
by the music signal. In other words, its power supply shrinks
and grows to fit the power demand.
In terms of its circuit structure, it looks sort of like a
small amp inside a big amp. Class-H has recently become
a large enough category to warrant a little more discussion.
Why? Because it is has become very cheap to produce so it
is becoming very, very common.
Basically, Class-H is a good idea which could be used
for good instead of evil… BUT in the wrong hands, it could
also be used to squeeze quite a bit of extra power out of
crappy single-chip amplifiers of the type that are used in
low-end boom boxes and car stereos and thereby form the basis
of some genuinely second-rate ‘Home Cinema’ systems.
So, if the whole thing comes in one box and looks too good
to be true – it’s probably from the ‘dark side’ of Class-H
and not something I would recommend.
Class-D
"The Devil's work"
Class-D
has been around a very long time but has only recently made
inroads into domestic audio systems. Modern manufacturing
techniques now make this once-impractical class quite economical,
so expect to see a lot more of it in future. It really only
has one outstanding advantage over the other classes and that
is amazing efficiency.
Sometimes (incorrectly) called a “Digital Amplifier” Class-D
operates a whole different way… so much so that I could write
another whole article about it but this one has to end somewhere,
so I’ll just give you the ‘executive overview’ for now.
In essence, Class-D seeks to leverage the most efficient mode
in which a transistor can operate i.e. ON or OFF. You could
think of a transistor as being a bit like the clutch in a
stick-shift automobile in that, it runs cool when it’s fully
engaged and also when it’s fully disengaged – but anywhere
in between, it’s getting hot.
So, if you can find a way to chop up an audio signal so it
just looks like a bunch of uniform on/off pulses and then
‘unchop’ it just before it gets to the speakers, you could
make some fairly small transistors produce quite a lot of
power. The method used is called “Pulse Code Modulation”
or PCM which is also a core technology of Compact Disc systems.
Up until recently, this type of amp was rare, and then only
found in some industrial applications such as P.A. and instrument
amplifiers but now that they’re easily mass-produced, they’re
finding their way into boom boxes and the ‘economy’ end of
home entertainment systems at a scary rate.
In theory at least, it is possible for a Class-D amplifier
to sound very good but in practice, I personally find them
a bit fatiguing and hard-sounding.
As far as I know, there are no Hi-End Audiophile amps that
use Class-D. I suppose that’s got to tell you something?
Conclusion:
At the end of the day, if you find something you like
and it's in your budget, don't let the class bother you --
but also be aware that things that sound exciting up front
can also become fatiguing and even irritating in the long
term. Classes D, G and H are becoming commonplace and look
like good value, at least on the surface but be very sure
about what you're buying.
Class-A will open up a tin of worms you may not wish to swallow...
for starters, your choices in speakers will be limited to
high-efficiency types to compensate for the low efficiency
of the amps. This is especially true of Single-Ended Triode
(SET) amps.
If you're prepared to live with the expense and other compromises
though, Class-A is the cream of the crop.
Most of the amps I like are Class-AB and this is usually a
pretty safe bet.
Back
Over
the last 30-odd years I have repaired literally thousands of audio
products. By mid 2004, I estimated that I had repaired over 5000
CD players alone. Audio systems I have worked on include domestic
Hi-Fi and Home Cinema, professional systems such as mixing consoles,
Digital Audio Workstations and sound-reinforcement, through to highly
specialised systems ranging from diagnostic audiometry, to complex
IFE (In-Flight Entertainment) systems for several major international
airlines.
Brands
of audio product I have worked on include:-